Peninsula Lake
Resort Heritage, Deerhurst Views, and 30 km of Pristine Muskoka Shoreline
$800K – $4M+
Huntsville (5 min west), Dwight (20 min northeast), Baysville (25 min south)
Known locally as "Pen Lake," Peninsula Lake is the prestige sister to Fairy Lake — wider open water, colder and clearer, and home to Deerhurst Resort where the 2010 G8 Summit was held. Its two named peninsulas on the northern shore create protected bays popular for sailing.
Peninsula Lake covers 840–869 hectares with a maximum depth of 37 m and nearly 30 km of shoreline, split between the Town of Huntsville and the Township of Lake of Bays. Water levels are controlled at two points: the outlet canal to Fairy Lake (excavated in 1888) and a water control structure at Fairy Lake's outlet. Seven commercial resorts operate on the lake including Deerhurst and Hidden Valley, plus Hidden Valley Highlands ski area — creating a rare four-season real estate dynamic. Fish species include walleye, lake trout, rainbow trout, and smallmouth bass.
- Part of the four-lake Huntsville chain — open boating access to Fairy Lake, Lake Vernon, and Mary Lake
- Lake trout habitat designation triggers 30 m vegetation buffer and dock surface area limits
- Hills Island and Wolf Island are privately held — island properties require confirming water-access-only status
- Hidden Valley ski area operates year-round, keeping demand stable across all four seasons
What Seth Watches for on Peninsula Lake
The canal connecting Peninsula to Fairy Lake is a federally navigable waterway — shoreline works within 30 m require Fisheries and Oceans Canada approval in addition to Township permits.
Seven commercial resorts operate on the lake's 30 km shoreline — noise, boat traffic, and seaplane activity peaks on summer weekends; carefully evaluate which bay your property sits in relative to resort docks.
Water level is managed at two control structures and spring snowmelt regularly overtops low-profile docks in the shallower eastern bays around Wolf Island — dock construction must reference the regulated operating range.
Adjacent residential properties sometimes carry premium expectations from Deerhurst's international profile that aren't supported by comparables — independent appraisals are essential.
What areas does Seth serve?
Seth specializes in cottage properties across Lake Muskoka, Lake Rosseau, Lake Joseph, and surrounding areas including Bracebridge, Gravenhurst, Port Carling, and Huntsville.
Get a Straight Answer.
Whether you're buying, selling, or just trying to understand the Peninsula Lakemarket — honest answers, no obligation, no pitch.